Right bully stick size offered to a dog according to chewing style

How to Choose A Bully Stick Size for My Dog?

You buy a bully stick because you want your dog to relax, not to create a safety risk. However, the size of the chew is more critical than you might think. Too thin, and it will be gone in minutes. Too short, and your dog will be trying to swallow the last piece. Too thick, and your dog will give up and go find your shoes.

Finding the correct size solves three problems at once: it makes it safe, it makes it last, and it meets your dog’s instinctive need to chew.

People often buy a specific bully stick size by the weight of the dog, but that’s only part of the selection criteria and you should also consider the strength of the jaws, the chewing habits, and their patience. For example, a 70 lb calm dog might need a smaller bully stick than a 25 lb aggressive chewer.

So instead of guessing, read this article to learn how to match the bully stick with your dog: big enough so they can’t swallow it, thick enough so they can’t chew through it quickly, and long enough so they won’t rush through it.

Bully Stick By Dog Size

The dog size provides a starting point, and although it isn’t the only criteria, it keeps you in the safe zone. In simple words, size is the guardrail, and the style of chewing fine-tunes it later.

Here’s a good rule: the chew should stick out on both sides of your dog’s mouth as they’re holding it. If the piece fits inside the mouth, it’s too small and can make them choke. 

Best Bully Sticks for Small Dogs

Small dogs need manageable chews rather than tiny ones. When the chew is too thin and too short, they shred it fast, try to swallow chunks, and then choking scares happen. You also want to provide certain resistance, not struggle, so the stick should be flexible but not break to keep them engaged and slow the pace.

Good bully stick options for small breed dogs are:

Avoid “spaghetti” style chews. They feel safe because they appear small, but they pose a danger since they’re very thin and tend to be swallowed quickly. The best bully stick for small breed dogs is one they have to work on, not one they can chew up in five minutes.

Best Bully Sticks for Large Dogs

For large breed dogs, length is the most important factor, while thickness stays in the second position because a thick short chew can still be swallowed. Long bully sticks force your dog to chew slower and to keep paws holding the chew instead of your dog trying to gulp it down.

Good bully stick options for large breed dogs are:

For extremely aggressive chewers, it’s essential to have bulkier pieces to prevent them grinding, as it can be easier to damage teeth by snapping pieces off. This protects their teeth and stretches chewing time.

The best bully stick for big dogs is always longer than you think they should be.

By Chewer Type

The way a dog chews determines the thickness. Two dogs the same size might need a completely different chew, as one might be a nibbler, while the other is a destroyer. This is the main reason why people buy the wrong bully stick for their pets.

To avoid mistakes, observe how your dog plays with a toy. Do they tear it apart or chew it slowly? That will give you an idea of what your dog needs.

Best Bully Sticks for Light Chewers

Light chewers are the ones who enjoy the process: they lick, soften, and work patiently, so they don’t require a large density. If too thick, they actually lose interest. That’s why these dogs require moderate resistance that provides them with a steady, enjoyable reward rather than frustrating chewing.

The best chewing options for them are:

  • Standard straight bully sticks
  • Medium thickness pieces
  • Short sticks (according to muzzle size)

These dogs don’t chew to win, but to relax. The right size keeps them engaged without making it a challenge.

Best Bully Sticks for Heavy Chewers

Heavy chewers crush toys into pieces, split seams, and try to beat the clock. Thin chews won’t slow them down, but encourage gulping, which brings safety risks.

These dogs need density and resistance, which helps protect the stomach from large pieces, not necessarily length. Here’s what to look for:

  • Thick sticks with real weight
  • Twisted that provide layering
  • Larger diameter cuts

If the bully stick flexes too much, it won’t last, but the right size makes chewing a job for them, so they focus on the snack rather than your home furniture and personal belongings.

Where to Find the Ideal Bully Sticks for Your Dog

After knowing the right size, the next issue will come up right away: not all bully sticks are made the same. Some are too dry and brittle, some smell awful, some fall apart too fast, and others will last an eternity but feel like a rock and will frustrate your pet.

The difference usually comes from how they’re processed, not just the size. Good bully sticks will feel dense but slightly flexible, it won’t splinter while chewing. That makes them safer and easier on the digestive system.

So, instead of shopping based on price and pictures, look for a few these features:

Bully sticks will soften as your dog works on them, ensuring the experience remains safe and relaxing, rather than "swallow it before it melts".

This is the approach followed by Bonez Treats. Our bully sticks are made with real beef, with no fillers, to ensure they remain completely digestible. If your dog likes to chew hard, thick bully sticks come in "twisted" and "jumbo" sizes. 

The goal isn’t just a chew that will last, it’s a chew that your dog will settle into. Texture is the key that will slow your dog down, calm your dog, and provide you with some real "quiet time."

The key understanding is: length controls safety, thickness controls durability. When you combine size and quality, you stop guessing, giving your dog a safe, satisfying, and worth chewing. Explore our options.

Back to blog